Main Navigation Menu

Alternatives

Tier 1 EIS Alternatives

Enhanced Service Concepts

Each of the Action Alternatives includes the adoption of enhanced service and precision operations concepts. These enhanced operating concepts represent national and international best practices, and are aimed at enhancing the attractiveness and convenience of train services, increasing the efficiency of operations, lowering the cost per capita of delivering rail service, and making the most efficient use of investments in new rail infrastructure, while providing flexibility for rail operators to deliver service that best meets the needs of the market in 2040. The links below provide more information.

Regular Clockface Schedules

Service Plans for the three Action Alternatives provide for regular schedules for all train services operating on the NEC. Trains operate at regular intervals, rather than on the basis of demand, as is the case today. Services operate at regular 15-, 30-, or 60-minute intervals, with local stations generally receiving two to four trains per hour during peak periods and major stations often receiving more service.

Metropolitan Service

All of the Action Alternatives introduce Metropolitan service, although the level of service and the performance characteristics of the service vary based on the railroad infrastructure and capacity provided in each alternative.

  • In Alternative 1, Metropolitan service share train slots with Intercity-Corridor-Other service, operate mostly over existing NEC tracks, and service is limited to no more than two trains per hour in the peak periods.
  • In Alternative 2, Metropolitan utilizes high-performance train equipment to provide four trains per hour, at regular 15-minute intervals, and services an expanded mix of Intercity and some Regional rail stations.
  • In Alternative 3, Metropolitan service utilizes high-performance train equipment to provide eight trains per hour stopping at expanded mix of Intercity and some Regional rail stations on both the existing NEC and on the new second-spine. For example, both Philadelphia 30th Street Station and the new downtown Philadelphia station on the second-spine are served by Metropolitan trains.

Run-Through Service at Major Stations

Regional rail run-through service, particularly applicable to Washington, D.C., and New York City, links branch lines from the different regional service operators and provides continuous revenue service on both sides of the metropolitan region through the Central Business District. It enables passengers to avoid transfers when traveling from one regional rail station to another through stations such as Penn Station New York and Washington Union Station. It also provides reduces dwell time at stations and reduces the number of train movements.

  • Alternative 1 retains the existing Regional rail operations with terminating services at Washington, D.C., New York City, and Boston. However, there may be opportunities to initiate limited new run-through service in the New York area, with LIRR trains operating through to New Jersey and NJ Transit trains running through to Queens and Long Island. Intercity trains provide the principal through-running service at Washington, D.C., and New York City.
  • Alternative 2 provides through running opportunities at both Washington, D.C. (VRE and MARC trains) and New York City (MNRR/LIRR and NJ TRANSIT trains). Through operations not only enhance connectivity for passengers and expand capacity, they make for more efficient use of trains and storage areas.
  • Alternative 3 similarly supports through-running operations, which permits the most efficient use of platform and track capacity at the major hub stations and enables the dramatic increases in total train volumes that are possible in this alternative.

High Speed Zone Express Regional Rail Service

This enhanced service concept is a significant feature of Alternative 3, offering substantially faster commute times for longer-distance commute trips from the outer suburbs. For example, Maryland outer zone Regional rail trains can use the high-speed tracks between Baltimore and Washington, D.C. Similarly, outer zone Regional rail trains in New Jersey can use the high-speed tracks on final approach to New York City to reduce trip times and relieve congestion on the local tracks. Alternative 3 provides opportunities for up to six or eight commuter express trains per hour from either Long Island or the Upper Harlem Line to Penn Station New York, depending upon the route option.

Coordinated Endpoint and Branch Line Connections

This includes the coordinated scheduling of Regional rail trains on systems that have multiple branch lines or multiple terminals, or where the outer ends of two regional systems meet at a common station (defined as endpoints), can provide for convenient passenger connections, extending the reach of the existing systems, substituting for costly extensions for one-seat-ride service, and providing a much more convenient transfer experience for rail travelers. Alternatives 1, 2, and 3 take advantage of opportunities for better connected Regional rail service at several locations on the NEC, effectively closing the gaps that now exist in Regional rail connectivity from one system to another. The Action Alternatives also improve connectivity between main line and branch line services at multiple locations.

Pulse-Hub Operations

A pulse-hub is a special application of service coordination, where multiple trains converge on a single hub station concurrently or in close succession, dwell simultaneously for a period of time while passengers transfer from one service to another, and then depart toward their various destinations. The Service Plans for Alternatives 2 and 3 provide for pulse-hub operations on the lower level of Philadelphia 30th Street Station with Intercity-Express, Metropolitan, Keystone Corridor, and Atlantic City trains all connecting with universal transfer opportunities every 30 minutes during the peak periods. The Alternative 3 route option from Long Island through New Haven, CT to Hartford, CT also provides a timed pulse-hub at New Haven.